Saturday, January 5, 2019

War Film Review


THE WHITE TIGER: A FILM REVIEW
By Stephen Wilson





One of the most outstanding films made in recent years is without doubt
The White Tiger. This war film, made in 2012 and directed by Karen
Shakharozarov, is a film about attempts to stop a sinister Tiger tank. It can
certainly claim to be original. Being blessed with a brilliant plot, talented cast,
thoughtful dialogue and subtle use of silence makes other current Russian
war films look stale and wooden. It thankfully lacks the cliched plots of two
soldiers soldiers struggling  to win the hand of one Russian female
soldier or the absurd melodramatic lines proclaiming how great it is to die
for the motherland. The recent 'Patriotic films' with lavish investment, poor
plots and special effects have become almost unwatchable. War veterans
practically never watch them.

The film is based on a novel by Ilya Bogashov. The plot centers around
a mysterious White Tiger tank which emerges from nowhere to destroy 20
Russian tanks only to vanish again into thin air. The Russians are stumped
as to how such a tank can fly over swamps and go through impenetrable
forests. Legends circulate among the Russians that this is no ordinary tank,
but a Phantom tank. After this White Tiger tank destroys many tanks, the
advancing soldiers discover that the driver of one Russian tank remains
alive. Despite suffering from 90% burns, the driver miraculously survives.
But losing his memory, they give him a new name Ivan Naydenov ,which
means 'found in tank'. Naydenov, played by Aleksey Vertikov, is not only
described as 'a phenomenon ' but regarded by most soldiers as 'a crackpot'.
"He should be in a lunatic asylum not at the front, " states one officer. This
is because Naydenov claims to be able to speak to tanks and worships the
God of the Tanks who dwells in the sky and protects him against the White
Tiger. When asked about the White Tiger, Naydenov states the tank is
dead and just fights as best it can. Naydenov has the gift of being able to
sense where and when the Tiger tank will emerge. So Major Fedotov, an
intelligence officer, played by Vitaliy Kishchenko, is ordered to take
command of a team of the best tankists of the Russian army in a new
prototype of an improved Russian T 34 85 tank. Naydenov is assigned to
take control of this crew with the goal of hunting down and destroying this
tank.

Naydenov's attempts to trap the White Tiger tank by using another T 34
tank fails. Not only is the T 34 tank destroyed, but the White Tank creeps
up behind Naydenov tanks and fires, but inexplicably fails to destroy them.
This stumps all the crew. They reckon that Naydenov must have some
special talisman or magic spell to protect him.

When Major Fedorov reports to his commanding officer that he now believes
Naydenov's claim that the Tank is 'dead', his commander retorts: "I believe
that there is God and the Devil. The war proves this! " Nevertheless, he doubts
the mystical explanations of the tank and even the sanity of Major Fedotov.
Seeing Fedotov as stressed out or mad, he grants him ten days leave.

The most strikingly memorable scenes of the film are when the German
commanders are forced to accept unconditional surrender. The tense
silence in the hall is eerie, especially when it is broken by a clumsy
photographer who trips up. In reality, journalists were not so tactful and were
pushing and shoving the generals to get a story.

In one of the last scenes Major Fedotov tells Naydenov : "The war is over
Naydenov, can you hear me ....The war is over. It is the end."
Naydenov answers "Until I destroy it, the war can't be over Major."
Fedorov claims: "It is gone. After the Battle of Vistula. It disappeared."
Naydenov retorts : "It is waiting. Maybe in 20, 50, or 100 years it will return.
It must be destroyed. You know that is what needs to be done ".

Indeed, as if to back up the words, the film ends with a haunting scene
of Adolf Hitler speaking to the Devil in Hell. Hitler claims that "There is no
beginning or end to war. War is the nature of things. We only did what
Europe was too scared to do or admit. That Bolshevism was a scourge
that has to be erased."

It seems that the White Tiger tank is an allegory of fascism and that it
can return anytime when we least expect it. Naydenov represents the
Russian soul and spirit who understands that Fascism needs to be
taken by the bull and the horns. What is more, it represents a kind of
deeply rooted metaphysical evil. Naydenov , who was reborn in the
war itself, also mysteriously disappears. Perhaps the film might also
best be understood by reading the Novel of Albert Camus, The Plague.
In this novel, Camus compared Fascism to the Plague and claimed
the microbes of the plague could lie in a chest until someone unwittingly
opens it. So a resurgence of Fascism can't be ruled out. Indeed,
current events in Europe appear to be vindicating  Naydenov's warning.
Fascism is winning growing support in both current day Italy and Germany.

The film is very thoughtful, deep and moving. But what do you think?
Does Naydenov really totally damage the White Tiger or has it just
vanished to bide its time? You just have to watch the film and draw
your own conclusions! The film can be watched on-line via You Tube
and has English subtitles.

No comments:

Post a Comment